Monkey D. Garp and Big Mom Fight on Whole Cake Island Not Ending Well or Garp in One Piece

In One Piece, fans are always talking about fights that may happen. Garp vs Big Mom is one of those what-if fights that people love to imagine. When thinking about who will win, it looks interesting at first, but not if they battle at Whole Cake Island. That makes everything unfair already. It’s not much of a balance if Big Mom gets to fight on her land.

Island Makes Big Mom Too Strong

Whole Cake Island is not just someplace; it’s like an extension of Big Mom. She controls so much there. With her Homies everywhere helping, she doesn’t even need to try hard. Garp can punch hard, and he's fast, too, yes. But that's not gonna help much here. On that island, she doesn’t even need to go all out. She was already winning from the beginning. That’s how it is.

Popular Games

View All

Garp Can’t Do Much In That Territory

Old Garp is still strong, no question. But against someone like Big Mom, with the whole island behind her, it does not look good. She is not alone when fighting. The trees, the ground, the weather – all of that moves for her. Garp can throw punches, but how long can he keep going while getting attacked by everything around him? People might not want to accept it, but she probably finished him quickly.

Fight Becomes More Fair In Another Place

Now, if a fight happens somewhere else – not in Whole Cake Island – then maybe the result is not so easy to guess. In a neutral place, Big Mom won’t get so much help from her power. Garp, if he were younger, too, could give her a hard time. In that kind of place, fans might see a real battle. Both are using what they have, with no outside help. That fight can go in any direction.

Many fans love this matchup idea. But where they fight, change everything. On Whole Cake Island, Big Mom is just too much. Garp is not weak, just in the wrong place. If it were somewhere else, maybe fans would talk differently.

Written By Manika Kayal, Intern, India Today Gaming.